Party Politics
Political Divisions, Texas Power Struggles and the Future of Data Centers
Season 5 Episode 13 | 26m 46sVideo has Closed Captions
Co-hosts Brandon Rottinghaus and Jeronimo Cortina delve into the latest news in politics
This week on Party Politics, co-hosts Jeronimo Cortina and Brandon Rottinghaus examine divisions in Congress over Iran and party leadership, a Texas GOP contest for the House Oversight Committee, razor-thin Collin County election results, Gov. Greg Abbott’s decision to reopen data center permitting, and Lt. Gov. Dan Patrick’s efforts to limit incoming Lt. Gov. Vikki Goodwin’s authority.
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
Party Politics is a local public television program presented by Houston PBS
Party Politics
Political Divisions, Texas Power Struggles and the Future of Data Centers
Season 5 Episode 13 | 26m 46sVideo has Closed Captions
This week on Party Politics, co-hosts Jeronimo Cortina and Brandon Rottinghaus examine divisions in Congress over Iran and party leadership, a Texas GOP contest for the House Oversight Committee, razor-thin Collin County election results, Gov. Greg Abbott’s decision to reopen data center permitting, and Lt. Gov. Dan Patrick’s efforts to limit incoming Lt. Gov. Vikki Goodwin’s authority.
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
Where to Watch Party Politics
Party Politics is available to stream on pbs.org and the PBS app.
Providing Support for PBS.org
Learn Moreabout PBS online sponsorship<Music> Welcome to Party Politics, where we prepare you for your next political conversation.
I'm Jeronimo Cortina.
And I'm Brandon Rottinghaus.
We're political science professors here at the University of Houston.
This was a kind of week where it was like a kitchen renovation level stress test for all of our patients, and really for how government functions.
Just keep in mind the following.
Right.
There's the Microsoft outage.
You've got the FAA, which had like a copper wire that I guess had to be replaced, that then got fixed and the flights were back online.
After a day and a half, you had a classified NSA network went down for hours, and bank problems in terms of connectivity, there's a lot of things happening.
Mostly people have said these are isolated incidents and don't want to get out the tinfoil and say that like there's some conspiracy happening, but there's definitely a government role in all of this.
And the question is, do you think that the administration is handling this properly because you have people like Josh Hawley, senator from Missouri, who says this is not a coincidence.
And there are folks like Gavin Newsom, the California governor, who's in D.C.
this week saying this is a masterclass in incompetency, or is it just coincidence?
And things all kind of go wrong at once.
Isn't that Murphy's Law?
Right, right.
I mean, I don't know, it could be one or the other, but what is clear is that the government is not equipped to do these things.
at once.
Remember, we have DOGE and a lot of cybersecurity folks were I guess, fired.
agencies may have been weakened by this administration.
In terms of response time.
It is clear that we have the FAA has old infrastructure.
The Biden administration allocated a lot of money, that money so far, it has been spent a little bit.
So those things need.
to hurry up.
And then, on the other hand, government by design is, I guess, built around slow responses.
Right.
Unless it's a natural disaster that now obviously with FEMA being hurt and slower, that is even slower.
But it's that's a whole design of public policy.
Public policy changes at a glacial pace.
So are we equipped to have these things ready?
I don't know.
Yeah.
That's the struggle.
And I think this last election was a call for accountability and transparency.
And I think that's one thing people were willing to you know, look forward to, look away if there is a problem.
Right.
Or to sort of suggest that this isn't as big an issue and that this can be solved.
But at this point, it doesn't feel like that.
It feels like a lot of dodging.
And that's something I think that the American people are really unhappy about.
So this definitely doesn't, like, sit well with, I think, most people after a very complicated, intense election.
So we'll see how this all plays out.
Maybe this is the end of it.
Or maybe, you know, we go outside and planes are flying out of the sky like, you know, hopefully not.
But this is the kind of concern that I think people have.
The government isn't functioning well.
And we can talk about how that plays out, because that's going to be really I think the fight over the next couple of years is how these things work all efficiently together.
And can they work efficiently together?
So we're going to talk more about that in the coming episodes, especially as the lame-duck session hits us.
But let's talk about the central figure on all of this.
And that's Donald Trump.
He's actually in Asia this week.
Okay, he's in the Philippines.
He's in China, and they're in China going to meet with the heads of state from China and from Russia.
Kind of trilateral meeting.
As the president got off the plane, he got a big hug from President Xi Jinping, which is unusual, according to the New York Times.
I don't see a lot of hugging going on with these national leaders, but that was unusual.
And in the Philippines, Trump got some late-night fried chicken, which sounds like the best perk of being president.
That and the bowling alley.
And never having to wait for always the best things about being President.
Yeah, I mean, it's, First he stopped in Manila in the Philippines.
He got late a little bit.
But, the most important thing is, is what's going to come up in these, in these, meetings with Xi Jinping and also with Putin.
And I think that Xi Jinping is playing the what he knows about Trump.
Right.
Trump wants to be received and greeted by the head of state.
That's why he got the hug.
Like I'll be there, you know, give you a hug and make you feel like.
You get a hug, too?
Or No?
Be in that extent.
So I think he's playing that card in Manila.
Xi Jinping said, you know what?
We are going to defend.
Free commerce from China, and we're going to not allow, you know, countries to be protectionist, right.
Mr.
Trump and then on the other.
Hand, towards him.
Yeah, right.
Putin said, like, you know, we're done with economic sanctions.
So what's going to come up with these trilateral meetings is going to be fireworks.
It's a good point.
Yeah.
And honestly, the last couple haven't really produced much by way of agreement like the 2025 Alaska summit with Putin made no headway on the war in Ukraine.
Last time.
You know, Xi and President Trump met.
There was very little progress towards easing trade tensions.
The fact is, too, you've got this kind of new NVIDIA scandal that is evolving, and the kind of chip issue has become more, you know, national news story, international news story now.
So these are all swirling around this complicated relationship.
And what's interesting is that political science does have a lot to say about presidents' foreign travel.
One of the things that becomes clear is that presidents can't avoid their problems by going abroad, that actually going abroad really is a net negative in terms of like your approval.
So this isn't really going to help the president, in part because the kind of public demand, certain kinds of responsiveness.
And if they don't feel like they're getting it because the president's out of town, then it can create this kind of sense that maybe the president really isn't necessarily on the ball, and that can create a lack of discussion about or something of the sort of priorities.
One thing it does do, though, is boost the approval of the foreign leader.
There's a really cool paper that talks about this.
So you're going to find Xi And Putin get more like a kind of approval from the president.
And I guess the hug is part of that story.
There you go.
Right.
Yeah.
But I think the president is trying to change the subject.
It was a tough election for Republicans.
One thing presidents can do is to look presidential by going abroad.
This is one of the most important things presidents do.
So it's not uncommon that we see them escape in this way.
If you deliver.
Right.
And yeah, if there's an outcome that's like, you know, something people like.
And, you know, since 2024, President Trump has said we're going to stop the war with Russia and Ukraine in 35 minutes.
And it has been years and nothing has happened.
And I don't think that Putin is going to say, yeah, whatever you want.
He's not going to do that because he hasn't done that right.
On the one hand, then on the other hand, President Xi Jinping has said, like, okay, you want to play hardball?
I'm going to play hardball.
Yeah.
And I don't think that given the, position of President Trump here domestically is going to help them.
I think that now they have the upper hand and say, if you want to deliver something, you are going to.
Have to basically.
Bend your hands and ask for something.
Yeah, that's a good note.
We'll see.
I think you're right.
And also, you know, this is a moment where Democrats are like looking to start to make inroads in terms of what their next couple of years are going to be politically.
And it's a point where Democrats can use this trip to, you know, essentially argue the president hasn't made progress on these things, like you said, and is really on the wrong side of public opinion on these things.
So, concessions to Ukraine and Taiwan are problematic.
Technology security issues are now, as we said a minute ago, seem much more pertinent than they did the week before.
So that's a potential kind of sort of an exposed problem for the president.
The other is that you're highlighting these difficulties of confronting China, like what is the plan?
And it doesn't seem like that's really evolved in a way that the president can say definitively that there's a solution to this.
So that also creates a kind of risk for the president to be abroad at this moment.
So he's trying to set his foreign policy for his legacy priming purposes.
Republicans are looking for him to try to understand what the foreign policy should be.
Marco Rubio, you've got, you know, Vice President Vance, even Ted Cruz are all thinking, how does this, you know, chess board look, at the end of the day when Trump is gone.
Yeah, but the chessboard is going to look all over the place, right?
I mean, all the pieces are going to be, you know, in, in, in places that should not be like the horse is going to be like, no, the horse shouldn't be there.
How did you get to the corner?
Exactly right.
Why did I do that?
But but.
Not even that.
He's not going to be following the rules of chess, because in terms of foreign policy, the big question is what has this administration accomplished in foreign policy that is a significant win for the administration?
Right.
I mean, that counts some wars and this and that, etc., etc.
but in reality we haven't seen that to the country.
The foreign policy has been heard and the position of the US, especially with our allies, has been weakened.
By any stretch of the imagination, Europe is pulling apart.
Obviously China is doing whatever they want.
Russia is doing whatever they want in Latin America is doing, you know, in certain countries not but most of the of the continent is doing those things.
So there is no clear wins that we say, yes.
The United States has asserted its role as a foreign policy actor because we're not anymore.
Yeah, no.
And that corresponds to the problem the president is going to face when he gets home.
That is a foreign policy problem, but also is increasingly a domestic problem.
And that is funding for the Iran war.
Now, we forgot about all this because we had months of election coverage like wall to wall, even dreaming about it.
So obviously we've pushed off some of these concerns, but we have to fund the government in December, and there's a real good chance that there's going to be a shutdown, because the difficulty of continuing the funding for the Iran war has presented political problems for really everybody.
So Congress may actually fund their way into a shutdown, because there's going to be a battle over the money for the Iran war.
Chris Van Hollen, who we talked about last week, is challenging Chuck Schumer for the Senate minority leader job, has been very clear that he wants to see the Democrats stand up and fight back.
They're in a slightly better position than they were before the election, because now they know that they'll have better leverage coming the next Congress, but they still have to pass a budget, or at least a temporary budget to be able to get through to the next Congress.
So that's going to be the real complication.
Democrats don't want to pass up a chance to have the first check on what Trump is doing in Iran.
This will be the first time that they can really do that.
So a handful of Senate Democrats want language blocking appropriations to Iran.
So that's setting up this fight.
So then really two questions are apparent.
Number one, can speaker of the House Mike Johnson get a clean resolution without Democratic votes?
I think the answer is no.
Even if that does happen and it goes to the Senate, can Thune, the majority leader there, get votes to support a budget without Democratic votes?
Or that can more or less get to 60 votes?
or can they more or less get to 60 votes?
So I think we're headed for a very realistic possibility of I hate to even say it, but a government shutdown, right?
I mean, the Delaney is December 11th.
It's around the corner.
And you have these two things.
Right.
Intraparty Within the Democratic Party, you have these leadership rifts in terms of Van Hollen and Senator Schumer.
And what's going to happen.
Who knows?
Right.
That's one thing.
But also on the other side, Republicans said, look It's going to be very easy.
If you do not approve these stopgaps and allow the administration stopping gap and allow the administration to spend another $350 billion right on these.
I thought you were kidding.
But that's the real number.
On these, War that we created.
Then that's going to basically torpedo all bipartisan negotiations.
And increase the mean.
That's it.
And a war the public largely rejected, right, in the last election.
So it does create those problems.
I like your point about the unity problem.
This is going to be a real test for democratic unity.
I brought up Van Hollen in particular, because this is really that divide, right?
They have to figure out what they're going to do.
Can they stay unified on this?
I think the answer is yes.
To me then we you you mentioned we don't know who's going to win that fight.
We don't.
But I think Schumer's got the edge because he's the better chance to be able to kind of rally the Senate Democrats at this point.
So that's one question.
The other is for Republicans, they face a growing divide about how to deal with the war in Iran, especially on war powers.
There are some Republicans who are willing to, you know, back the president, but many who are saying we want to have a little bit more clarity, and we want to be able to have Congress assert themselves and their foreign policy.
So this is going to be a real test for the growing divide inside the Republican Party.
That is implications.
I hate to even say it for the 2028 presidential cycle which begins right now.
Yeah.
So that's really, I think, another kind of conundrum that they find themselves in.
I mean, because these guys are going to be some of them fighting for reelection.
Yeah.
So yeah.
And for the Republican nomination for president.
Yeah.
A lot of things are at stake here.
Yeah, we'll keep monitoring this because this is going to happen in a very delicate moment for the country.
Right.
The holidays are coming.
People don't pay that much attention to politics, but it's going to be a really tough fight going forward.
Speaking of fights, another one that involves folks from Texas.
And so that's why we bring it up.
So you've got two representatives who are trying, Republican representatives who are trying to duke it out to become basically President Trump's chief defender on the House oversight in the next session.
Representative Pat Fallon, Representative Brandon Gill, they're trying to become the ranking member of the Republican Party for House oversight.
Their job will basically be to do much of the defense against what the Democrats are likely to come up with in terms of these hearings and investigations.
They're both staunch conservatives.
They both have raised lots of money for their colleagues, but they have different tactics.
Fallon has said he's more of a kind of knife fighter.
He's been through more of these battles, Brandon Gill says.
He's got a bigger kind of social media following.
He backed Ken Paxton in a very public way in the election, and I think to some degree is looking to kind of get credit for that.
So this is really an important fight for Texas because it really is a kind of stepping stone to leadership in the next Congress.
And we don't know what will happen.
You know, sort of four years from now.
But for sure, it's the case that there's going to be a lot more churn than before.
And we said last week that Texas doesn't have a lot of leaders in the mainstream Republican Party these days.
So our clout has basically minimized whoever wins this.
It'll be from Texas, but it'll be a question about what the tone looks like, but also kind of what that trajectory looks like.
Well, yeah.
And the interesting thing is, is Fallon, you know, serving the Texas House and the Senate.
He is older, perhaps, as you say, maybe, you know, it's not older, like, you know, very.
Old John Cornyn and old.
Right.
Sorry.
But you know, it's it's more unknown.
He's a Gen Xers.
To put it mildly.
Is he really.
Yeah.
So he's not old.
At all?
No, he's absolutely not.
He's young, energetic.
And then you have Brandon Gill I think he's around 30.
32.
Yeah.
So it's a different way of.
How.
A real flamethrower too, right, like this is I mean, I don't want to set this up as, like, a kind of old versus new establishment versus insurgent.
But to some degree, it is like that, right?
I mean, they're both in the same kind of wing of the party.
But Gill definitely sees himself as a kind of future leader.
You're talking about potentially somebody who is a statewide office holder, potentially in the Republican Party.
The question here, in terms of the, battle between these two styles, is that Texans were very clear what they wanted, right.
Gill is a first term congressman.
Yeah.
Like delivering is extremely important, right.
So I don't know what's going to happen.
I don't know what's going to be.
You know, he's from the same school like Jim Jordan, right?
Yeah.
And then.
No, you.
Need to bring substance.
Yes.
But also you need to materialize that substance.
Something has to happen.
And just as a kind of side note, this is inside baseball for Congress.
But there's a kind of proxy battle happening.
And so you bring up Jim Jordan.
It's really good because there is this sort of, you know, difference inside the party about how to proceed on these issues.
And conservative.
Yes, they all are.
But this is really a question about tactics and about tone to some degree.
So, and one more thing to what is what's going to happen to the Republican Party.
Yeah, after President Trump finishes it.
Yeah.
And that's the question.
So you know, you had you know, Brandon Gill aligned with Tom Emmer, who became the House minority whip.
Fallon sided with Austin Pfluger, who he said last week didn't get the job, who was also from Texas.
So there's a kind of proxy battle happening underneath.
And really, the insurgents were winning, right?
The Jim Jordan camp is winning and Gill is on that side of things.
And so we'll see how it plays out.
But that's really the sort of dynamic I think, that could define.
Yes, the future of the party.
Right.
That has serious implications to what's going on next.
Let's shift gears and talk about Texas itself more.
And I think this is a great example of how everyone's vote counts.
Yes.
In Collin County, my hometown, Chairman Leach won by 128 votes.
Representative Richardson won by seven votes.
Seven votes!
I know.
Let's talk about the way that this, of course, signifies that the votes are really close and this is going to be competitive elections going forward, especially in key counties like Collin County.
Let's let's talk about the changing nature of Texas.
That's a whole thrust of the discussion from the election from, you know, a couple of weeks ago.
And Collin County is really the epicenter of much of that.
So here are two Republicans who are barely holding on, but did hold on by a very small margin.
So number one, every vote counts, right?
Yes.
If somebody says, I don't think my vote matters, it matters, right?
Chairman Leach, by the way, is my parents' representative, and that's two votes.
I'm sure they voted for him.
That's two votes that they don't.
Yeah.
28.
Yeah.
Seriously, like that is such a small number that it's stunning.
But the bigger picture is about Collin County, right.
And about the way that this has changed.
You've got this demographic change, which is in part because you've got an influx of people from all over the state, but also from other states.
You've got a booming economy, you've got more people who are college educated.
This is changing the nature of Collin County.
Every time I go back, it's stunning to see the way that this has evolved since I was growing up there.
And it's really interesting to see.
And that really is, I think, the kind of way that a lot of these suburbs are going.
Right.
You can look at the areas around Austin.
Oh yeah, around Houston, right?
Fort Bend County.
So there are all these huge things that are happening.
And this is really the tale of how the state is changing politically.
So what do you make of all of this?
This is very, very, very, very good.
Right.
Why is it very, very good?
Because having these close elections puts representatives and elected officials accountable.
Yeah.
Now it is like, I won with seven votes.
Yeah okay.
Yeah, yeah seven votes.
You got to pay attention now.
Yeah.
And then it's 128 votes.
That's nothing.
It's like Truman said, right?
Just pay attention and answer your mail.
Make sure you exactly services or I. Think I think this is very good because then they're going to be on the defensive but also on the offensive.
So once again, what voters want, especially in these counties, is that elected officials deliver and deliver and improve quality of life.
So I think this is, you know, frankly, it's very good that elections are so close.
Yeah.
Let's talk about something else.
That was a big issue in the election.
That's data centers.
We remember the that the governor paused the applications for new data centers until they could do an environmental study that apparently has been done.
And the governor has ordered the Texas Commission on Environmental Quality to lift the pause on new permits.
What do you make of the politics behind this?
You're you're you're you're smiling.
Well, this was implemented in July.
Yeah.
When the big issue of data centers and the revolt around the state was going all over the place.
So the governor before the election stopped it.
And now, you know, after the election is open.
I mean, look, I think and we have said this before, data centers are here and data centers are not going to disappear, right?
Yeah.
There's ways of thinking about how you do these things.
Right.
Can you use, for example, all this water that has been used by fracking to cool down these data centers?
So are they going to be in a particular place in the middle of nowhere?
Right.
So those are the things that we need to think about and how we can use, for example, closed cooling circuits to cool down?
Are they going to have small modular reactors to power these things?
So those are the things that we need to think.
And obviously the impact of the to the environment and to the land.
So I think that I haven't had a chance to absorb the report.
The report.
Yeah, yeah, good.
But we'll tell you what, you read that and you tell me every detail about what is in it.
Okay, I will, I'm, I will.
Or you have ChatGPT tell me what it tells you.
Right.
That's a good way to summarize stuff because there's lots of stuff in this report, right?
I mean, this is a technical report.
And that was the thrust of it, like, basically there's going to be an environmental impact to this.
And the question is, what is it?
And is it worth the cost?
That's the real question.
Now, this week the Texas Tribune had a really cool story, my friend Paul Cobler has been working on this thing for a long time, that basically suggests that the data centers are costing the state more like $1 billion a year.
Right?
In terms of tax breaks, the generation of jobs maybe isn't so obvious from that.
And so there's no there's no job generation, you say.
Right?
It's modest, but it definitely it doesn't necessarily outweigh the the kind of offset.
But those things about you know that report once I read it I can tell you a little bit more.
But but the issue is is okay, counties and municipalities for a long time have been like attracting economic development.
Right.
And we used to give the baby, the bathwater, and the bathtub to those investors.
It's like, yeah, sure.
And the knobs and yeah.
Thank everything right.
Giving away the county.
Right.
I think that now in certain counties and I can say this in Fort Bend County, it is the opposite.
We are going to do a win-win situation here.
You win but we win.
We're not just going to give away the county for whatever purpose it is, because it's exactly what you're saying.
We're in the long run.
We're going to be losing money.
So I think that those are the things that we need to to think about and how to minimize environmental impact.
That is very, very important.
No.
That's right.
And I think part of this is about transparency.
Right.
Is it being kind of government being open enough about the process and about what is really being lost and gained here?
And that is a trade-off.
Like every decision is a trade-off, right?
And so as you say, you have to figure out where that line is for the county and for the municipality that's giving these tax breaks.
It's also a bipartisan issue because we're definitely going to see this.
Oh yeah, front and center in the next session.
My guess is this is going to be the first thing out of, you know, the governor Hinojosa's mouth, that we should do something about data centers.
Exactly.
What they do will be the subject of kind of that negotiation, but we're likely to see this be something that everyone wants to do something about.
So we'll certainly see this back.
Let's talk about last.
Dan Patrick cannot quit the Texas Senate.
He said more or less, that he thinks that the Senate should strip Vikki Goodwin of these powers, which they can do.
Remember, the rule rulemaking capacity of the senators is pretty significant.
They can basically turn her into the vice president.
That is, they won't have any real legislative role.
So they can take away her power to assign committees, her power to push legislation through calendars, committees, the ability to appoint chairpeople, just a lot of things.
They can't take away some of the constitutional responsibilities she has.
But what do you make of Dan Patrick's sort of, we'll say, kind of continuous efforts in the Texas Senate, which he has largely shaped right.
The most important lieutenant governor in history.
What do you make of his continual involvement?
I mean, like, you lost the election.
The the people of Texas spoke.
And that's it.
I mean, like you have to respect that because that was the main argument, right, that Republicans used in the state House and the Texas Senate.
Right.
And we said absolutely.
I mean, we said it here.
People voted that way.
End of story.
That's what the people elected.
So if the people elected something else right.
Right is like, wait, what?
Like, so now it is not about the principles of democracy?
So if we are going to be democrats, small d, then we have to be democrats.
It's not like, oh, I'm a Democrat when you know I'm in power and then I'm not.
So I don't think it's genuine.
Yeah, I think it's a political like, look, it's problematic for Republicans because they're going to have to essentially sort of play puppet master through Dan Patrick.
And that's, I think, not a good look.
Like you said, the voters are very clear that's not what they wanted.
I think some of the senators would like to do some bipartisan actions.
And Patrick really wasn't having it right.
He was in power.
Now he is out of power.
The question is, will they respond?
This is going to be the real fight going forward.
These senators are going to be essentially the center of the political universe, not just Texas, but the nation.
And we're going to find out about those things starting next year.
I am Jeronimo Cortina.
And I'm Brandon Rottinghaus.
The conversation keeps up next week.
<Music>
New Episode- News and Public Affairs

Top journalists deliver compelling original analysis of the hour's headlines.
New Episode- News and Public Affairs

Today's top journalists discuss Washington's current political events and public affairs.
New Episode
New Episode
New Episode
New Episode
New Episode
New Episode
New Episode
New Episode
Support for PBS provided by:
Party Politics is a local public television program presented by Houston PBS